
The Messy Table
Loving Ideals or Loving People?
Fresh starts are intoxicating. They offer a season of hope—a chance to remake ourselves and learn from our past. We leave behind the baggage of previous mistakes and step forward into fresh air. In those early moments, the future seems full of endless possibilities: deep friendships, world-changing conversations, and a perfectly harmonious community.
Then, reality sets in.
A conversation goes off the rails. A past wound is triggered. Your shadow self emerges in a time of stress, and you find yourself slipping right back into old patterns. Suddenly, you find yourself yearning for those early days when everything was new and fresh, before you were stuck in the messy reality of actual people and complicated relationships.
When the illusion shatters, we have a choice to make. Do we run back to the open air, hoping to find a new, flawless community where we can successfully remake ourselves? Or do we settle into the mess of the relationships, allowing the friction to rub off our rough edges and shape us into something new?
I have chosen the easier path of walking away more times than I am comfortable admitting.
Starting college in a Christian community was fueled by teenage idealism. I hoped everyone would be perfectly aligned in love and a common goal. I donned the happy mask and dived into this new community, believing it was my chance to leave behind old wounds.
It did not take long to realize that not everyone shared the same motivations, and that my own unhealed wounds deeply dictated how I interacted with others. What started as a hopeful, "easy" path quickly emerged as a stark reminder that I had hard work to do. I had to face my own flaws and genuinely enter into the mess with the people around me. Every single person at the table is telling their own story and bearing their own scars.

In the ancient text of John 13, Jesus had stepped into a dining room and we find them sitting exactly like he has done hundreds of times before. The food is on the table, his closest friends are seated around him, and they are grazing over the Passover meal. But the putrid vapours of the road on the men’s feet, intermingling with the savoury smells of the dinner, remind everyone that a crucial step has been missed.
The moment stretches into an awkward silence. The men look at each other, waiting to see who will lower themselves to do the dirty deed, only to realize their Rabbi is already bringing the basin to the table.
I have been a part of many leadership transitions where the incoming leader pulls out a basin and washes people's feet as a symbolic act. Often, individuals in the room roll their eyes at the performative nature of the show. But for Jesus, this was anything but a show.
Jesus knew he was preparing to lay down his life. He also knew that the men sitting at that table were about to abandon, deny, and betray him. They were the furthest thing from the "ideal" community. Yet, he wasn't afraid of their messy reality. He didn't demand they achieve perfection before he served them; he met their flaws with a towel and a basin.
Conversely, I have been in a number of communities where relationships sour. Factions form, selfishness emerges, and where there was once unity, there is now only discord. In all transparency, I have participated in my own versions of this conspiracy through the years and left hurting people in my wake. In these situations, each side holds up their pristine ideal as the singular "right" way forward. We love our dream of the community more than the actual people in it, and in the end, everybody loses.
When we demand a pure, pristine perfection from others, we completely miss the environment where actual growth happens.
It is in the friction that we discover what true love looks like. True spiritual formation does not happen in a flawless utopia; it is forged when we look across a messy table at frustrating, complicated people, and choose to pick up the towel anyway.
But let's be honest: it is much easier to read about a towel and a basin than it is to actually live it out on a Tuesday afternoon. Our default setting is to treat these stories as beautiful, symbolic metaphors while continuing to expect the people in our offices, homes, and microchurches to meet our unspoken standards of perfection.
We don't need more performative acts of humility. We don’t need the "show." We need practical environments where our idealism can gently die so that real, gritty love can take its place. True community begins when we stop looking for the perfect group and start offering our un-curated, un-distracted selves to the flawed people right in front of us.
To help us ground this truth in our actual schedules this week, we are honing in on three specific invitations. These are not a checklist to prove your worth or a script to perform; they are simply practical ways to step into the mess. Take what is helpful for your current season, and leave the rest behind.
Practices
These practices are not meant to be prescriptive, but invitational. Your worth is not determined by whether you succeed or fail, but by the fact that God loves you and is inviting you into relationship. Take what is helpful, and leave the rest behind.
The Agenda-Free Dinner. Invite someone outside of your immediate, comfortable circle over for a casual meal (like pizza or tacos). The only rule: there are zero strings attached, no networking, and no deep spiritual lesson to teach them. Simply offer the radical hospitality of your presence and embrace the ordinary reality of sharing a table.
The "I Need Help" Text. Many of us love playing the role of the capable helper, but we hate being vulnerable and admitting our limitations. Text someone in your network and ask for a small, practical favour; borrow a tool, a ride, or a quick hand with a household task. Invite them into your mess.
Stretch Practice: The Burden Takeover. Identify someone in your network who is clearly underwater (a new parent, someone navigating an illness, or a stressed colleague). Don't ask, "How can I help?" Tell them, "I am dropping off dinner on Thursday night" or "I am mowing your lawn this afternoon."
Resources for the Month
If you want to dig deeper into moving past the ideal and embracing the beautiful, gritty reality of sharing life at the table this month, here are a few brilliant resources to pick up:
- Microchurches by Brian Sanders – A masterclass in redefining "church" from a destination you visit on Sunday to a micro-community of real people sharing ordinary life and mission.
- Life Together by Dietrich Bonhoeffer – The classic, foundational text on why our romantic dreams of community must die so that real, honest relationships can live.
- The Tangible Kingdom by Hugh Halter – A highly practical, field-tested guide on how to live out a missional incarnational lifestyle with your actual neighbours without the religious jargon.
- Brave Cities by Hugh Halter – An inspiring look at how to reconstruct the way we think about business, community, and faith ecosystems in a local context.
A Question for the Table
If you are gathering with your microchurch, family, or friends this week, ask this question: "Where do you find it hardest to let go of the 'ideal'—in your marriage, your parenting, your workplace, or your faith community? How is that ideal keeping you from loving the actual, complicated people who are sitting right in front of you?"
